Weight Class - Statistics show that if two vehicles with the same NHTSA full frontal rating crash into each other head on, but one vehicle weighs twice as much as the other, the occupants of the lighter one (2000 lbs / 909 kgs) are eight times more likely to be killed than the occupants of the heavier vehicle (4000 lbs / 1818 kgs).  However, vehicle weight offers no safety advantage or disadvantage in single-vehicle crashes.

Weight Class Categories

 3500 lbs / 1590 kgs or more
 3000-3499 lbs / 1363-1589 kgs
 2600-2999 lbs / 1181-1362 kgs
 2300-2599 lbs / 1045-1180 kgs
 Less than 2300 lbs / 1045 kgs

Keep in mind that crash test results shouldn't be compared among vehicles with large weight differences (more than 15%), so we have divided the vehicles into 5 distinct weight categories.  

The weight we use is the specific weight of the vehicle used in the  test that was conducted.  Very often a differently optioned vehicle will weigh 10% more or less than the weight we've assigned to it.  Please re-adjust the weight class category to meet the exact weight of your vehicle. Different engine, transmission, and accessory option packages can make a big difference.  The weight class rating for a any given model is not set in stone.

NHTSA released a new study in October of 2003 that further examines the differences in weight.

Weight reductions in passenger cars, lighter vans, pickup trucks, and sport utility vehicles (SUVs) increased the risk of fatal crash involvement, a study by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has concluded. The study of 1991-99 models also found that large four-door passenger cars and minivans had the lowest fatality rates of all vehicle types.

The study, done on the recommendation of the National Academy of Sciences, found that:

  • Modest (100-pound) weight reductions in heavier (3,850 to 5,000 lbs.) light trucks and vans (LTVs) had little net effect on crash fatalities.
  • Modest weight reductions in the heaviest LTVs (greater than 5,000 lbs.) were associated with a reduction in fatalities in other vehicles.
  • One hundred-pound weight reductions in lighter LTVs and most passenger cars significantly increased fatality risk.
  • Large 4-door passenger cars had the lowest fatal crash rates followed closely by minivans. The highest fatal crash rate was observed in small 4-door cars, mid-sized SUVs and compact pickup trucks.

Two factors accounted for the difference in fatal crash rates between large passenger cars (average weight 3,596 lbs.) and mid-sized SUVs (average weight 4,022 lbs.). Mid-sized SUVs were nine times as likely to involve a rollover fatality and twice as likely to cause a fatality in occupants of other vehicles. In non-rollover crashes, the fatality rate for the occupants of SUVs and passenger cars of similar weight was essentially equal.

The study examined fatality data from 1995-2000 involving 1991-1999 model vehicles. Researchers adjusted the data to account for differences in driver age and gender, rural versus urban driving and other variables such as nighttime driving.

The full study is available on the NHTSA web site at: http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/rules/regrev/evaluate/pdf/809662.pdf.


Weight Matters - The following chart is from an IIHS News Release dated 2-10-98.  The left-most column gives the weight class of the vehicles in the first column of each pair (that is, " cars," "pick-ups," & "SUVs").  Columns 1, 3, and 5 show the death rates (per million vehicles per year) for cars, pick-ups, and SUVs of different weights; columns 2, 4 and 6 show the death rates for the occupants of the other vehicle in the two-car collision.  

Occupant death rates in two-vehicle crashes, 1990-95 model passenger vehicles versus other vehicles ( deaths per million vehicles per year)
Weight Class (lbs) Vehicle crash pairs 1990-1995
Cars  Pick-ups SUVs
Cars 

Other 

Pick-ups

 Other  SUVs Other 
less than 2500 
109 35   105 58
2500-2999
 83 43  89  88 54  75
3000-3499
 60 48 56  116 53  75
3500-3999
53  57  52  115  37  92
4000-4499
49 58 44  144 29 91
4500-4999
    45 169 29 110
5000 +
    38 181 25 112

(Of note, occupants of the lightest cars have dramatically higher death rates.  Also, most significantly from a safety point of view, heavy pickups and SUVs are associated with far higher death rates in the OTHER vehicle than in themselves, or than death rates caused by comparably heavy cars. ) 


(Source IIHS)

   Index (Internet Explorer)|Index (Netscape)
Content © 2005-2006 Crashtest.com® Inc. All Rights Reserved.